Prudence Mary Morton (abt. 1811 – living 1 November 1875)

An Irish-born settler of Hungerford Township, Hastings County, Ontario

Prudence Mary Morton was born in Ireland about 1811. In both the 1861 and 1871 censuses she was recorded as Irish-born and a member of the Church of England. Her reported ages in those returns place her birth in the second decade of the nineteenth century.¹ ²

A baptism for Mary Morton, daughter of James Morton and Margaret Johnston, was recorded on 6 April 1809 in the Church of Ireland parish of Clones, County Monaghan.³ This is the only parish register entry presently identified for a woman of that name and age in the locality associated with the Doonan family.

She married James Doonan in Ireland, and by the early 1830s they were living in Canada West, where their children were born. The recorded birthplaces of the children show the family moving through the Bay of Quinte region — from Prince Edward County to Belleville and then to Hungerford Township in Hastings County — where they established their permanent home.


A farm household in Hungerford Township

In 1861 Prudence appeared in the census in Hungerford Township in the household of her husband, James Doonan, a farmer. Both were recorded as born in Ireland and as adherents of the Church of England. Their children, all born in Canada, were living with them on the farm.¹

Ten years later, in 1871, the household had entered a later stage of life. Only one son remained at home. Prudence, then fifty-seven years old, was again recorded as Irish-born and Church of England, and the census noted that she could not write.²


The home farm: Lot 8, Concession 1

Land registry records identify the family property as the north half of Lot 8 in the First Concession of Hungerford Township, Hastings County.⁴ This was the farm on which Prudence spent her later life.

On 13 August 1873 James Doonan made his will. In it he devised the farm to his son Edward, together with the livestock and farm implements, but required that Edward provide for the support of his mother during her lifetime. Prudence was to have the room she then occupied in the house and was to be maintained “winter and summer.” She also received a cow and two sheep for her own use.⁵

James Doonan died on 19 September 1873 in Hungerford Township.⁶


Widowhood and legal protection

Prudence survived her husband and was living as his widow on 1 November 1875, when she appeared in a mortgage and a related agreement with her son Edward concerning the farm. In the mortgage she was explicitly described as:

“Prudence Doonan, widow of James Doonan … and mother of the above-named Edward Doonan.”⁷

Because she held a life interest in the land under the terms of her husband’s will, her consent was required when the property was mortgaged. The agreement made the same day set out how her support would be secured:

  • if the farm were sold during her lifetime, she was to receive $200
  • if she chose to live elsewhere, Edward was to pay her $20 per year in place of her maintenance on the farm⁸

She signed the document by mark, consistent with the earlier census notation that she could not write.² ⁸

These records provide a detailed account of the arrangements for her old age and show that her right to support was formally protected against the land itself.

Part of the land record recorded 1 Nov 1875.

Last record

Prudence’s last known appearance is in the agreement of 1 November 1875.⁸ No later record has been found.

Her life can be traced with certainty from her Irish origins to more than four decades on the same farm in Hastings County, where she lived first as the wife of a settler farmer and later as a widow whose maintenance was guaranteed by the provisions of her husband’s will.


Sources

  1. 1861 Census of Canada, Canada West, Hastings County, Hungerford Township, household of James Doonan; Library and Archives Canada.
  2. 1871 Census of Canada, Ontario, Hastings East, Hungerford Township, household of James Doonan; Library and Archives Canada.
  3. Church of Ireland parish register, Clones, County Monaghan, baptism of Mary Morton, 6 April 1809; Family History Library microfilm 897416.
  4. Hastings County Land Registry Office (Ontario), Abstract Index to Deeds, Hungerford Township, Lot 8, Concession 1.
  5. Hastings County Land Registry Office (Ontario), Will of James Doonan, dated 13 August 1873, registered 27 September 1873.
  6. Ontario death registration, James Doonan, 19 September 1873, Hungerford Township, Hastings County.
  7. Hastings County Land Registry Office (Ontario), Mortgage from Edward Doonan and Prudence Doonan to John Taylor, registered 1 November 1875.
  8. Hastings County Land Registry Office (Ontario), Agreement between Edward Doonan and Prudence Doonan respecting her life interest under the will of James Doonan, registered 2 November 1875.

My Irish Connection

James Doonan was born in Ireland around 1796-1799. He was married to Prudence who was a bit younger – born in 1811 in Ireland. Due to the destruction of records over the years in Ireland, I cannot say who their parents are with any certainty. James and Prudence immigrated to Canada by 1835 as their first known son was born in Canada in 1835. James and Prudence would ultimately have 10 children (that are known): John born February 7, 1835; Elizabeth born April 10, 1836; William born September 29, 1837; James born April 13, 1839, Armour born December 29, 1841; David born April 20, 1843, Edward born November 20, 1844; Alexander born May 8, 1846, Johnston born March 19, 1848 and Sarah Ann born June 2, 1851. William is my second great-grandfather, making James and Prudence my 3x great-grandparents.

Several years ago, I had hired a researcher to try to find out more about the ancestors of James and Prudence. The report that was generated lacked documentary evidence, but supposed that James parents were William Donan and Jane Glenn. It also supposed that Prudence’s maiden name was Morton and her parents were James Morton and Margaret Johnson. I really don’t know if this is true or not. In 2012 I made a trip to Northern Ireland – to Belfast – to do research and found there were no records to support or deny these claims.

I talked to another researcher who claimed that Prudence’s maiden name was Johnston – like her last son’s given name. It’s not unusual for a son to be named after the mother’s family – sometimes using the surname as a given name for the child. Then there is this curiosity from the 1861 Census of Canada:

Screen Shot 2018-03-16 at 9.08.09 AM
1861 Canada Census, Hungerford Township, Hastings County, Canada West (aka Ontario).

There’s the Doonan family living seemingly next door to a Johnston family whose parents were born in Ireland. Prudence is 13 years older than James Johnston here which means they could possibly be siblings. It would not be unusual for siblings to immigrate to a new area and live next to each other. So, there certainly seems to be evidence supporting the Johnston surname – although quite honestly it’s not proof either.

Most of the Doonan’s remained in Canada, but John and William moved to Michigan sometime in the 1860’s. John would immigrate to Bay county and die in 1900 in Roscommon and William came to Bay City where he was married 4 times (most likely divorced 3 of those 4 times – but no divorce records are found, nor death information for 3 of the 4 wives).

John Doonan was married on April 10, 1861 in Bruce, Ontario to Eliza Jane Walker. Two of their 10 children were born in Canada. William J. born 1861 in Canada, Prudence E. born October 28, 1863 in Canada. Then they moved to Michigan where Francis was born in 1865, Elizabeth born 18 May 1868, Eliza Jane born 1870, David born June 21, 1874, Sarah A born 1876, Ruth born March 14, 1879, Amanda born July 1882 and Charles born November 14, 1884. Coincidentally, after John’s death, Eliza Jane would re-marry in 1903 in Higgins Township, Roscommon, Michigan to Samuel Johnston who was born about 1846 in Canada. At this time it is unknown if Samuel Johnston has any connection to that Johnston family from the 1861 census.

William and his fourth wife, Rosa Smith, would have 10 children – 8 of whom lived to be adults as far as I can tell. Frank, born  June 30, 1896 and Pearl born May 25, 1905 are both buried in Fraser Township Cemetery in Bay County. Sometime between 1905 and 1910 (probably 1908) William moved with his wife, 4 sons and 2 of 4 of his daughters back to Canada. The two daughters who stayed in Michigan were married – Rose Jane Doonan born August 22, 1882 was married to Alonzo Davis, and my great-grandmother, Margaret born on June 2, 1888 was married to William Henry Lacy in 1907. William would ultimately commit suicide on October 13, 1913 in New Liskeard. Rosa would re-marry in 1918 to Ernest Ball. William and Rosa’s sons, James, William Nelson, Archie and Abraham Possinger would all serve during World War I in the Canadian Expeditionary Force.

Howard Rivers, William Doonan, Alvin Rivers, Archie Doonan
Howard Rivers, William Doonan, Alvin Rivers, Archie Doonan and 2 other Doonan relatives (not sure of their names). Picture taken on a trip of Howard and Alvin with their mother to visit the Doonan cousins in Cobalt, Ontario Canada in the 1950’s or early 1960’s.

(Ellizabeth) Sabria Lacy, Howard Rivers, Margaret Doonan, R
4 Generations: Rosa Smith Doonan Ball, Margaret Doonan Lacy Phillips, Elizabeth Sabria Lacy Rivers and Howard Rivers. Picture taken in Colbalt, Ontario, Canada probably summer 1952.